Unmasking Discrimination

Religious Freedom on Campus

When our religious freedoms are being attacked, we must not remain silent. And one group of college students is speaking out loudly and clearly. Good for them. I’m Eric Metaxas, and this is BreakPoint.


Eric Metaxas

Imagine a college chapter of the People for the Ethical Treatment for Animals, PETA, being led by someone whose favorite food is nice rare steak and who wears fur coats whenever she can. Sounds pretty wacky, doesn’t it?

Well, for Christian groups at Vanderbilt University something like this is a real possibility. So they have decided to fight back in a way we could all learn from.

Back in January, the university put out new regulations aimed at student political and religious groups. The regulations require that “membership in registered student organizations [be] open to everyone and that everyone, if desired, has the opportunity to seek leadership positions.”

Theoretically, under the regulations, a PETA chapter at Vanderbilt — if one exists — would really have to admit, and possibly be led by, a fur-draped carnivore. I’m guessing that’s not what the Vanderbilt administration had in mind. But I do have an idea whom they are targeting: Christian groups.

You see, last fall, Vanderbilt told the Christian Legal Society that its requirement that officers “lead Bible studies, prayer, and worship” violated university policy because it “implied that these leaders must hold certain religious beliefs.”

Call me cynical, but it’s hard to imagine the university admonishing a campus Gay and Lesbian group for requiring that its leaders support same-sex marriage. Or can you imagine them telling the local Hillel chapter that it must accommodate Jews for Jesus? I don’t think so.

The regulations are such a blatant example of what lawyers call “viewpoint discrimination,” that campus Christian groups are fighting back: a coalition of eleven religious student groups called Vanderbilt Solidarity is reapplying for registered status at Vanderbilt without changing their membership requirements.

Their goal is to make the university publicly explain and justify its blatantly discriminatory policy. They may not prevail in their quest for registered status but even then they will have done us all a service by refocusing the debate on the issue: religious freedom.

Far too often, the debate over religious freedom gets sidetracked: as Chuck told BreakPoint listeners, Rush Limbaugh’s boorish comments were — no pun intended — a godsend to HHS and its supporters. The focus on contraception distracted Americans from the real issue: the use of government power to coerce believers to violate their religious beliefs.

It was a pointless alternative to the questions Americans ought to be asking themselves: if Christians can be forced to pay for contraceptives, sterilization, and abortion-inducing drugs, what else can people of conscience be forced to do?

Taken at face value, Vanderbilt’s policies, as Robert Shibley of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education has noted, would allow heterosexual students to join the Lambda Association and vote it out of existence.  Once again, I kind of doubt that’s what university officials have in mind.

So hats off to Vanderbilt Solidarity. They’ve placed the onus where it belongs: on university officials. And they’ve made it clear what really is at stake in these debates: religious freedom for all.

Further Reading and Information

Vanderbilt University Insults Our Intelligence
David French | National Review Online | March 30, 2012.

Campus Crackdown
Chuck Colson | BreakPoint.org | March 15, 2012.

Vanderbilt Solidarity Statement
Christian Legal Society | April 9, 2012.

Watch Your Tongue
Chuck Colson | BreakPoint.org | March 6, 2012.

April 17, 2012 Vanderbilt to religious students: Are your beliefs really that important?
Robert Shibley | Daily Caller | January 31, 2012

Breaking the Spiral of Silence DVD
Consider hosting an event on April 28, 2012.

Do you want to learn how to discuss today’s cultural issues from a Christian viewpoint? The Centurions Program gathers Christians together to learn how to live out their faith authentically and powerfully in the world and unites them in an ongoing and growing network of worldview movement leaders. Find out more about joining soon because the deadline is May 18th.

Comment Policy: Commenters are welcome to argue all points of view, but they are asked to do it civilly and respectfully. Comments that call names, insult other people or groups, use profanity or obscenity, repeat the same points over and over, or make personal remarks about other commenters will be deleted. After multiple infractions, commenters may be banned.