Crazy Justice for the Mentally Ill


What to do with mentally ill criminals? That question has been nagging the justice system for 30 years. Well, it’s time to figure it out. Stay tuned to BreakPoint.

Eric Metaxas

In 2005, Andre Thomas was convicted of killing his wife and children. Everyone agrees he did it. What we should do with him is another matter.

What I’m about to describe is definitely not for younger listeners. Older listeners should keep listening, because Thomas’s case raises serious questions about what it means to “do justice.”

As detailed in a recent issue of Mother Jones, after killing his family, Thomas cut out his children’s hearts to ensure “that the demons inside each of them would die.”

Well, if you’re thinking, “Thomas must be crazy,” you haven’t heard anything yet: Thomas actually believed that his wife was Jezebel and his son was the Antichrist.

Now we’re not making light of this. If you wonder whether Thomas “must be faking it,” you should know that when he was ten, he tried to saw off his own arm with a butcher knife. Three weeks before the murder, he tried to commit suicide and ended up in the hospital. A hospital physician noted that, “[Thomas] is psychotic.”

Well, just how psychotic? Reading the Bible in his cell, he came across Matthew 5:29—“If your right eye causes you to sin, gouge it out . . .” — and he did just that.

What psychiatrists call “auto-enucleation” is extremely rare and an almost-certain symptom of severe psychosis.

Despite this and a lot more evidence that Thomas is insane, he was charged with capital murder, convicted and sentenced to death.

Prison officials have no trouble describing Thomas as a “paranoid schizophrenic.” And that’s not surprising, since, while on death row, he gouged out his other eye, and consumed it.

Regardless of your opinion on the death penalty, executing a man who should have been declared insane is not justice, and it does not protect the public. Andre Thomas will never again be a free man.

But mental illness is more than just a sentencing problem. It’s also a crime-prevention problem—as you’ve no doubt heard in the gun-control debate. Too often, when the mentally ill come into contact with the justice system, instead of treating them, we throw them in jail or in prison.

And that solves nothing. Not only do the mentally ill take up scarce prison space that should be reserved for dangerous criminals, when they return to the streets—and they will—they are more likely to pose a danger to society precisely because they won’t have been treated.


That’s why Justice Fellowship, founded by Chuck Colson in 1983, is supporting the Justice and Mental Health Collaboration Act.

The bill sponsor in the House is Republican Rep. Richard Nugent, who served as Sheriff of Hernando County, Florida. Rep. Nugent says “After thirty-seven years in law enforcement, I have seen far too many tragedies result from mental health needs that went either unnoticed, untreated, or misunderstood. This legislation will help give law enforcement the tools and training they need to improve the way that our legal system interacts with individuals suffering from mental health crises.”

The bill has bi-partisan support, and Justice Fellowship would love it if you could support it to. Come to, and we will link you to all the information you’ll need about the Justice and Mental Health Cooperation Act. You’ll also be able to learn more about Justice Fellowship’s work for biblically-based criminal justice reforms.

Folks, this is a vitally important subject. Christians, above all, need to stand up on issues like this. People like Thomas are unable to speak for themselves; we need to speak for them. So please go to and let us know how you feel.


BP-Takeaction_32013Crazy Justice for the Mentally Ill: Finding a Better Way – Next Steps

Eric has spoken on a very difficult subject. We sometimes feel helpless with the deep problems in our society, especially in the area of mental illness and criminal behavior.  Justice Fellowship, a sister ministry with The Colson Center, is actively addressing  this situation. But they need help from many people. Visit Justice to see how you can be a part.

You can go directly to the “Take Action” page Eric mentioned by clicking here, showing your support for the Justice and Mental Health Collaboration Act. You may also like to sign up for the Justice Fellowship Newsletter.

As Eric mentioned, we would like to hear your feedback on this commentary. Please post comments below.


How Crazy Is Too Crazy to Be Executed?
Marc Bookman | | February 12, 2013

Madness in the Streets
Chuck Colson | | August 21, 1992

American Gulag? Treatment of Mentally Ill Prisoners
Eric Metaxas | | August 21, 2012

Bedlam: Prisons and the Mentally Ill
Mark Earley | |August 6, 2007

Helping the Mentally Ill
Kristine Steakley | |September 27, 2006


The Justice and Mental Health Collaboration Act

Justice Fellowship sign up

Comment Policy: Commenters are welcome to argue all points of view, but they are asked to do it civilly and respectfully. Comments that call names, insult other people or groups, use profanity or obscenity, repeat the same points over and over, or make personal remarks about other commenters will be deleted. After multiple infractions, commenters may be banned.