‘Noah,’ Mass Entertainment, and Us


The movie “Noah” certainly has struck a nerve among Christians. And I’ve got some thoughts about that. Stay tuned to BreakPoint.

Eric Metaxas

In 532 A.D., a series of riots pitting the supporters of two different chariot racing teams, the “Greens” and the “Blues,” nearly toppled the Byzantine Emperor, Justinian. The Nika riots resulted in 30,000 deaths and half of Constantinople being burned or otherwise destroyed.

If it sounds like these people took popular entertainment far too seriously, well, you might Google “Noah” and “Christian.”

As several colleagues of mine have pointed out, the level of vituperation among Christians over Darren Aronofsky’s film is “nuts.” In the most-recent high-profile salvo, a theologian accused Christian leaders who endorsed the film of missing “a blatantly Gnostic subversion of the biblical story when it was right in front of their faces.”

This of course prompted denials and retorts from those being criticized. As my BreakPoint colleague Roberto Rivera put it, “and the wheels on the bus go round and round.”

As Roberto pointed out in a recent column at BreakPoint online, what’s missing in all the back-and-forth “is any consideration about why Christians should be so invested in what comes out of Hollywood.”

He’s not saying that we shouldn’t take note of what the entertainment industry is up to. Of course not. Given its outsized role in our culture, to ignore it would be folly. Nor is he saying that we shouldn’t be prepared to praise the good stuff and criticize the rest.

But he is saying that we shouldn’t look to the entertainment industry for validation of our beliefs and way of life. And that, sadly, is what too many of us are doing. We long to see ourselves—or an idealized version of ourselves—on the screen. Like Sally Field said at the Oscars 30 years ago, we want to say “I can’t deny the fact that you like me, right now, you like me.”

But while Field was being humorous, many of us aren’t.

What makes this especially unfortunate is that mass entertainment is, almost by design, intended to be a substitute for the Christian worldview that answered what Brad S. Gregory, a historian at Notre Dame, has called the “Life Questions.”

According to Gregory, consumerism, including the consumption of mass media, grew out of the rejection of Christian ideas about the good life and human flourishing. As he put it, we have exchanged the “good life” for the “goods life.”

These “goods” aren’t limited to cars, houses, and electronics. They include mass media: TV, music, movies and the internet. Even more than tangible “stuff,” mass media distracts us from the emptiness and the purposelessness of much of modern, post-Christian existence.

That’s why “people who couldn’t begin to tell you about the biblical Noah can talk your ears off about ephemeral pop culture matters.” In many instances, it’s the only thing they can talk about.

There are of course exceptions. Some films and TV can serve as illustrations of Christian themes and “conversation starters.” But as my friend says, “the goal of such illustrations and conversation starters should be to direct people’s primary gaze away from the screen (of whatever size) and toward the places where the ‘Life Questions’ are supposed to be answered,” such as in scripture and worship—not to mention in fellowship and in acts of service.

So let’s leave the online rioting to fans of chariot racing.

Please come to BreakPoint.org and click on this commentary and we’ll link you to Roberto’s excellent article on “Noah”. We’ll also point you to resources on the intersection of Christianity and mass entertainment. And if you liked this commentary, why not share it with your friends on Facebook and Twitter and let them know about BreakPoint? We’d certainly appreciate it.


“Noah,” Mass Entertainment, and Us: The Search for Validation

As Eric pointed out, Christians must be careful where we get our validation from. One place we ought not look for it is to Hollywood.

Below we have listed a few classic resources on the intersection of Christianity and mass entertainment that will help you think through the issue.


Get Off My Lawn: Why Are Christians Fighting so Hard about ‘Noah’?
Roberto Rivera | BreakPoint.org | April 3, 2014

Undrownable Truth: ‘Noah’ Brings Together Legend, Controversy, and a Surprisingly Biblical Message
G. Shane Morris | BreakPoint.org | March 28, 2014

Not Sermons, but Stories
Eric Metaxas | BreakPoint.org | August 22, 2013

A Peek behind the Toob
Eric Jacobson | BreakPoint.org | Spring 2003

Amusing Ourselves To Death
Neil Postman | Penguin Books

Hollywood Worldviews
Brian Godawa | IVP Books | 2009

Reel Spirituality
Robert Johnston | Baker Academics | 2006

The 20th Century Art Form
Kim Moreland | BreakPoint.org | September 10, 2003

Comment Policy: Commenters are welcome to argue all points of view, but they are asked to do it civilly and respectfully. Comments that call names, insult other people or groups, use profanity or obscenity, repeat the same points over and over, or make personal remarks about other commenters will be deleted. After multiple infractions, commenters may be banned.