BreakPoint: The Golden Age of Education Innovation

There Are Alternatives

What happens if your school district crosses a line with its curriculum? What do you do now?  Here are some words of encouragement.

Last month, we learned that the Orange County California Board of Education will not allow parents to remove their kids from classes that discuss “gender, gender identity, gender expression, [or] sexual orientation.”

Now, parents have apparently found a loophole: They can remove their children from the entire sex-education program, just not from the specific parts they don’t like. An attorney for the Orange County Department of Education failed to mention that detail when he announced to parents they “do not have a constitutional right to excuse their children from portions of the school curriculum they find objectionable.”

Sorting through the back and forth and sleight of hand to keep your children out of ideologically-opposed classes is a nightmare. And it’s not just in California.

Across the country, curriculum is being used to force students, even grade schoolers, into a set of beliefs about gender and sexuality that run contrary to the Christian view of creation, not to mention common-sense morality.

In Illinois, the Senate passed a bill requiring public schools to teach “the roles and contributions of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people in the history of this country and this State.” If passed by a Democrat-controlled House, it will take effect next year. There’s no sign that this rising tide of public school indoctrination will ebb.

So Christian parents face tough decisions: whether to keep their children in government-run schools or find some alternative. Let me repeat something I’ve said before: There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Each family will have to make this choice for themselves, considering the options available to them given a lot of considerations.

Even so, millions of parents have reached the end of their patience, and are searching for alternatives. Maybe you’re one of these parents, too. If so, I’ve got some good news: We’re living in what might be the golden age of education innovation.

Within my lifetime, the number of options for teaching Christian students has exploded. Not just homeschooling, which thanks to organizations like the Homeschool Legal Defense Association, is now well protected in most states. There are also charter schools, co-ops, affordable Christian schools, even online classes.

My colleague Warren Cole Smith and I gave a few inspiring examples in our book, “Restoring All Things”—projects like Cornerstone Schools in Washington, D.C., which offers pre-K through twelfth-grade to 200 students in a disadvantaged part of the country, or like Brookstone Schools in Charlotte, North Carolina, where ninety percent of graduates perform above their grade level in one of the worst public-school districts in the state.

Today, almost one in twelve American students attend religious schools, and another two million are homeschooled. That number will certainly grow in the years to come as all of these choices become mainstream alternatives to public education. Finding ways to teach children outside of public schools isn’t some marginal practice anymore. It’s normal. And as demand increases, so will our innovative options.

There’s still a lot of work to do, of course. As Neil Postman observed, the problem with most public education isn’t just that it often teaches the wrong things, but that it fails to teach, period. In place of a targeted, coherent education, it often gives students mere proficiency in a set of skills. Worst of all, it doesn’t prepare them to deal with the wild and often dangerous world of ideas.

Right now, I’m working with Shane Morris, another colleague of mine—himself educated in a hybrid homeschool co-op setting—on a new book to help with that problem. Our field guide to help Christian students identify ideas and worldviews, and to understand their consequences will be available later this year.

All of this should encourage you. Christians might still choose public schools, and many do. But if you live in a district that you feel has crossed the line, there are alternatives—lots of them. It’s not impossible, folks. And look, we’re in this together.


The Golden Age of Education Innovation: There Are Alternatives

Christians parents and teachers are right to be uneasy about the direction our national and local educational systems seem to be heading. The links below provide some reasons for concern. But as John said, there are alternatives. Check out the links in our Resources section for just a few examples of the educational options available for the next generation.




Comment Policy: Commenters are welcome to argue all points of view, but they are asked to do it civilly and respectfully. Comments that call names, insult other people or groups, use profanity or obscenity, repeat the same points over and over, or make personal remarks about other commenters will be deleted. After multiple infractions, commenters may be banned.

  • Just One Voice

    Thank you for the resources & suggestions! I think our local school district is green to go. But if I ever have concerns over the curriculum, I will definitely come back to BP and explore recommended options. I think Focus on the Family and similar bodies have good resources too.

  • ah.1960

    I’m ashamed to admit that when my children were still too young for school, my thought process was that we would send our kids to public schools and simply “correct” any unBiblical ideas they might learn during the day. Thankfully, my wife was more tenacious in wanting to homeschool and so that is what we did. I acquiesced and we took it a year at a time. Now, after all of them have graduated from our homeschool and gone on to be Christian adults, marry Christian girls, and have careers of their own, I can say without question, that if I had it to do over again, I would homeschool. I promote this option, but this does not mean every Christian must do likewise.

    But the battle concerning education does not stop there. I have seen kids graduate from Christian colleges where they have accumulated large amounts of debt and even more tragically walked away from Christ. Others attended state colleges, got involved with Cru or other Christian ministries, graduated with far less debt and maintained or strengthened their faith in Christ.

    Within the church we need to do a better job of teaching both parents and children to have a Biblical worldview and apply it to every area of life, whether education, politics, economics, law or morality. Then regardless of the mode of education, they can be that shining “city on a hill” that holds forth the truth of the gospel to a world that so desperately needs the love of God.

  • Parents need to really do their homework regarding their kid’s schooling – their future is at stake.