BP_blog
A Greek Tragedy

Ending the Entitlement Mentality



Those who do not learn from Greek tragedies may be doomed to repeat them.

Listen Now | Download


Chuck  Colson

Some are calling the financial crisis in Greece a Greek tragedy. Well, in ancient Athens, Greek tragedies were well known; the strong central character suffered some self-inflicted misfortune, usually the result of his hubris, or pride.

What’s going on in Greece today may not be the result of pride, but it is certainly self-inflicted and definitely tragic. Greek debt is 152 percent of the nation’s annual Gross Domestic Product. That kind of wild spending is insane.

And now the Greek government is between a rock and a hard place. Their creditors are demanding drastic spending cuts. Meanwhile, the Greek populace has gone nuts, rioting in the streets over cuts to their extensive social programs. And in this financially interconnected world of ours, the economic collapse of a country the size of Alabama threatens to hurl the global economy into chaos.

Not a pretty picture! Could such a Greek tragedy ever be played out in the United States? Yes: it can be, it will be if we can’t summon the political and national courage to cut the deficit and cut it now.  But such courage is hard to find in Washington these days.

This week, the Congressional super committee must release its plan to cut $1.2 trillion from the budget over the next 10 years. If the committee fails it will trigger automatic cuts divided between domestic and defense spending. And already we’re hearing talk of Congressional leaders plotting ways to undo the automatic cuts. This is pure political cowardice.

Folks, this is the easy part. That $1.2 trillion in cuts is just the down payment on more cuts to come to bring our fiscal house into order. And as Erskine Bowles and Alan Simpson of the presidential commission on deficit reduction have said, we are facing “the most predictable economic crisis in history.”

If a group of Congressman can’t make cuts that are absolutely necessary, we have to wonder whether we have lost the capacity for self-government.

The truth is that our leaders are afraid to tell us the truth: We can’t continue to spend money the way we are doing without going broke. We have to cut our programs, including and especially entitlements.

But that’s the message Americans don’t want to hear. Beginning in the 1960s, we started believing that the government had an endless supply of cash — and the responsibility to give us whatever we wanted. The American people, American politicians, and maybe our entire system have become captive to the entitlement mentality.

Just last week the American Association of Retired Persons had a press conference and challenged the super committee: AARP will not accept any cuts to Social Security or Medicare. Members were screaming at the cameras. Folks, this is Greece right here! Even if we taxed everyone at 80 percent we couldn’t keep paying for Medicare and Social Security the way they’re going.

We’ve got to face reality. And you should be telling your representatives we can’t go on this way. We have to cut entitlements, and the super committee had better not come out from behind closed doors empty handed.

If we can’t learn from what’s going on today in Greece, then we are indeed in the middle of a tragedy of our own making. And heaven help us, because it will mean we can’t help ourselves.

Further Reading and Information

Bowles to supercommittee: ‘I’m worried you’re going to fail the country’
Felicia Sonmez | Washington Post | November 1,2011

Bowles and Simpson vs. do-nothingism
Jennifer Rubin | Washington Post | March 9,2011

 




Comments:

Responses
If we don't adjust the future trajectory of entitlement spending while not punishing current recipients too severely, then the day may come when these benefits are simply not available due to an extreme lack of resources This seems to be the issue. Common sense should tell us that this charade cannot continue, but common sense has all but disappeared, along with courtesy, civility and willingness to sacrifice. And Washington has certainly shown no proclivity as a whole for either honesty or statesmanship. Ironically, an ancient Greek statement would be apropos here: Whom the gods would destroy, they first make mad. Hopefully, that won't become our epitaph.
S.S.Insurance
I have auto insurance. Last week I hit a Deer and totaled my vehicle. If my auto insurance had robbed all my money and had no money to pay me when I needed it, the company would be libel and be part of a federal investigation. When we started paying it SSI it was the same. Insurance is supposed to be there when we need it. Instead, congress has robbed it and now you call it an entitlement. It's not an entitlement, it is insurance. We pay in and we get back. Entitlement is for those who never pay in and still get the support they don't deserve. Prisoners get better care and more support then our elderly. Maybe you should get out of the prison and hang out with the elderly that are trying to live on your so called entitlement. Or better yet, maybe you should try to live on social security only and see if you still think it is an entitlement.
Social Security
My deceased husband and I paid loads of money into Social Security. If you cut it, I die. I have no other source of income. Why not make the wealthy pay the same proportion of taxes as the poor does? The Lord always had a preferentil option for the poor. Do you?
A Greek Tragedy
It's not only a Greek tragedy, it's the Roman approach all over again: panen et circeses (bread and circuses). It's also a sad example of the blind leading the stupid exactly where they insist on going.
Overspending is a Moral Problem
We must cut spending at the federal, state and local levels. We can not spend our way to prosperity.