BreakPoint Blog
|
A Trip to Heaven and Back By: Anne Morse|Published: February 23, 2011 3:07 PM Rating: 2.00 I just finished reading Heaven Is for Real, by Todd Burpo (with Lynn Vincent), about a four-year-old boy named Colton Bumpo. While undergoing life-saving surgery after a misdiagnosis nearly killed him, Colton visited Heaven, sat in the lap of Jesus, and then came back to describe what Heaven looked like and who he saw there. Sounds like the typical near-death experience, huh? I don't always believe these stories, but Todd Burpo is a small-town Nebraska pastor who tells this story with great care, years after the events took place. It's one thing to have your child say he sat in the lap of Jesus, which could be dismissed as a dream by a child familiar with Christian teachings. Harder to explain are the things Colton told his parents over the next few months. For instance, he told his mother that he'd seen his "other sister" in Heaven. Colton's parents had never revealed to him that they'd lost a baby years before Colton's own birth. Colton also told them he'd seen his great-grandfather, who had died decades before Colton's birth. When his parents showed him a photograph of his great-grandfather as an old man, Colton didn't recognize him. But when they had a relative unearth and mail a picture of the great-grandfather when he was a young man in his twenties (a photo that included other people), the four-year-old promptly identified his great-grandfather. Colton also correctly described what both of his parents were doing when he was in surgery (his dad was in a small room yelling at God for abandoning his family, and his mother was elsewhere, praying and phoning friends and relatives). Their son's stories got the Burpos thinking more about the reality of Heaven. But the main reason they wrote the book was to offer comfort to people who had lost loved ones, especially children and babies. After telling their story in church and elsewhere, it became clear that people were finding great comfort in what Colton said he had seen: many, many children. Perhaps this book will be used to comfort the many women who regret their abortions by helping them understand more fully that their lost babies are with God. As I write this, Heaven is for Real is currently at number 12 on the Kindle bestseller list, and number 100 on the New York Times bestseller list. It's a short but amazing book. I couldn't put it down. |


Comments:
If that's your definition of easiest then the easiest possible explanation for a complex issue is almost always going to be wrong.
If the engine on your car dies, which is the easier explanation.
1. Angels done it
2. The seal on your water pump failed causing the engine to heat up and fuse one of the pistons to the piston housing.
Here we can see how using an easiness test will not give us a useful answer... though there is something intuitively appealing in blaming it on an anthropomorphic force.
It is not however the easiest explanation. Technically the easiest(most simple, concise and digestible) explanation is that the boy actually did go to heaven.
1. There exists a magical land that human essence is transferred to by an unknown process, and even the existence of this essence is unverifiable and works by no known force. This child was able to be transferred, accrue memories (which, as far as we know should be stored in his physical brain, but they were able to be stored even when he didn't have access to that physical brain.) He then came back and told his story over a series of months, but didn't ever hear his parents talking about anything that had happened while he was under, instead all of this information was gleaned by divine revelation.
or
2. A child was mistaken, and his parents took the story he told as a proof of something they already were inclined to want to prove.
I'm not saying that you can disprove heaven, that's not really inside the scope of knowledge, I'm just saying that heaven is not the most plausible explanation for this book.
How, for instance?