BreakPoint Blog

Banner
Banner
'50 Shades of Grey': How should the church respond?


"Here's the deal," states Jenny Rae Armstrong in her post about E. L. James's publishing phenomenon. "Women you know are reading this stuff. Women in your church are reading this stuff. They’re just not talking about it. They’re ashamed, and flying under the radar to avoid detection.

"Also. Your daughters are reading this stuff. Or their friends are at least telling them about it. Bella Swan was bad enough--do you really want your babies to grow up wishing they could be just like Anastasia Steele?"

Jenny's written a very important post here, asking some questions that badly needed to be asked. Though I took issue in the comments section with some of her remarks of classic literature (had to uphold the Unwritten Code of the English Major, after all), I think she's exactly on point with her interpretation of this particular series. After all, there may be several ways to interpret "Beauty and the Beast," but there are distressingly few ways to interpret a novel whose heroine "willingly and excitedly agrees to spanking, whipping and gagging."

Jenny's treatment of the books and what they signify is pretty frank, but as she convincingly argues, when "the three best-selling books in the nation right now are about a 21-year-old girl who has sold herself into sexual subjugation," frankness is exactly what we need.


Comments:

Ignoring the hype in the paint section of Home Depot, how many shades are there, really, of black and white?

So I think, Gina, that the Church should do what it has always done - shine light into dark places. When we do that, as Dennis indicates, darkness tends to flee.
A Christian friend of mine posted on Facebook how great this book is, she was still reading it, and everyone should read it. I hadn't heard of it so I looked it up and couldn't believe she was recommending this. I confronted her on it and asked her if she would let her 16 year old daughter read that book and if not then why is she reading it. Well she got to the distasteful parts and quickly changed her tune and rescinded her recommendation. But it points out how we need to know what we are reading before we read it. Just because a book is popular doesn't mean it is a book Christians should read or promote.