BreakPoint Blog

Banner
Banner
Lent Goes Green


On Wednesday, Christians around the world will once again enter into the season of Lent, a time of reflection on the sinful nature of humanity, and on its need for redemption. With the imposition of ashes on their foreheads, churchgoers will be reminded that they are but ashes, and to ashes they will return. They will look heavenward to the One who has sacrificed Himself to save them from death and the grave.

Or not.

Just in time for the next liturgical season, the Washington Office of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), with an assist from the National Council of Churches, is offering a “2010 Lenten Journey on Climate Justice.” The weekly devotional series will focus on the effects of climate change on health, economics, development, migration, and food security, with a special focus on climate justice for Holy Week. The series is intended as a supplement to last year’s "Creation Waits with Eager Longing" worship resources.

To be fair, Christians are called to be good stewards of God’s creation. However, using the penitential season of Lent to promote human efforts in curbing climate change is at best misguided, and at worst a fundamental misrepresentation of the nature of redemption.

The Ash Wednesday worship resource from 2009 is an example of the ELCA’s new focus. Proclaiming scientists (presumably only those with the most dire of predictions) as “eco-prophets,” the authors urge worshippers to respond “with actions of justice and compassion.” (Since biblical prophets proclaimed God’s sovereignty and pointed to the ultimate arrival of a Messiah, one has to wonder exactly what faith these “eco-prophets” are proclaiming.)

The authors of the Lenten materials tie the proposed environmental activism to the ELCA slogan, “God’s Work, Our Hands.” Although there is a need for Christians to serve others through God-given callings, the purpose of Lent is not to examine what can or must be done. Quite the opposite—it is a call to reflect on what God has done for us that we couldn’t do on our own. It is not a matter of “our hands,” but His pierced hands and feet.


Comments:

I read a portion of the linked resources...Some verses, etc. on the work on the cross...actually some good verses about justice... But---having been in a church which pushed away personal repentance in favor of "social justice", I shudder... My limited guess...Some do not really believe much (anymore) in the work of Jesus on the cross...so they (mostly) substitute current important causes and sorta push the Passion Week to the background...This might not be a fair assessment as I only read a portion of the linked resources..
Actually, Jason, ;-) I was going for reductio ad absurdum: here the churches are charging full-tilt to be so green that they might even consider using fake ash for something that is deeply symbolic and minor in its environmental impact while putting those palm fronds on the eco-friendly compost heap, and yet the rest of the world is now putting on the brakes as we discover that indeed, much of the climate change "science" was in fact fraudulent. To avoid the minor offense of hijacking Steve's thread, I'll send the "your stimulus dollars at work" link about the Portland (Oregon) federal building with the stimulus-funded green garden ascending 250 feet to Gina, separately, instead of describing it here. ( :-) ) But the major offense belongs to the ELCA and NCC for hijacking not merely a thread, but an entire contemplative Christian season, for political purposes. These would be the same people, if memory serves, who have doubts about the historicity of the Resurrection, but who swallow climate "science" whole - and drag their parishioners with them.
Well said.
Be careful Lee, lest that be interpreted as an argument from novelty. If a change is pernicious then lagging behind IS leading the way.
To be fair, the ashes are recycled. (Traditionally, they are the charred remains of the palm branches used in the previous year's Palm Sunday service.)
I hate to ask questions like this to fill in the gaps in my knowledge, because it's so difficult to phrase the questions in a non-offensive way, but, ummm, how do they produce the ashes for all those foreheads? Is it by reducing portions of what once were trees to (gasp!) carbon?? Wouldn't synthetic ash (say, cosmetics produced from minerals or something) have a reduced ecological footprint? Like I say, I hate to be insensitive, but if Lenten observers are really gonna go green, they shouldn't be making mere symbolic gestures. :-) // On another, related point, it appears that Christians are once again lagging behind the rest of society, instead of leading the way: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/environment/article7026317.ece // I echo the other commenters; great job, Steve.
And ideally, it would mean the state of Virginia would refund my taxes, since no one ever bothered to plow my neighborhood and I still can't get out of the development without assistance. Hey, I'm starting to like this "economic justice" idea. . . .
Economic justice makes perfect sense. It means making sure the $15.00 the County owes me for a long boring day doing jury duty arrives quickly.
Heh.. Watch it there, Mike; someone might think you have something against the Left. ..//.. Steve, beautifully said.
"Climate Justice"? What a bastardization of the word justice. The left has done this decades with "economic justice," which really has nothing to do with justice and everything to do with the politics of envy, the equality of results, redistribution of wealth, socialism, the hatred of capitalism and the West, and the absolute confidence that government can accomplish their egalitarian goals. Associating the word with climate makes even less sense, but we all know it means the exact same thing as "economic justice."
Great points.