An Immigration Compromise

By the looks of things, it seems that compromise on the contentious issue of immigration is unlikely, if not impossible. The House’s position has been hard-line: We have to stop illegal immigration before we even consider ways we could process illegal immigrants into America properly. Some members have even demanded the wholesale deportation of all illegal immigrants, which would virtually stop the American economy in its tracks. The Senate has taken what’s regarded as a more moderate approach: securing the borders and establishing a guest-worker program so that people who have been here for a while can establish their residence. President Bush’s position on the debate has been, in my opinion, comprehensive and responsible. Yet here we are in July, and instead of ironing out their differences, the House and the Senate are holding dueling hearings across the country. While getting agreement is hard to imagine, the basis for a good compromise exists. It addresses the important issue of border security while also offering a humane way of dealing with illegal immigrants already living in the United States. It even has a role for Christians who, after all, are commanded to care for the strangers in our midst. The author of this compromise is Representative Mike Pence (R) of Indiana. I have known Pence for several years and regard him as one of the brightest young stars in the House. He is a serious Christian who is committed to integrating faith and public service. What Pence is proposing is a two-step process. The first step is to secure the borders. His proposal would include the enforcement measures passed by the House last December. Once the Secretary of Homeland Security certifies that the borders have been secured, illegal aliens will become eligible to apply for guest-worker visas. Pence’s proposal requires them to leave the country and apply for these visas at what he calls “Ellis Island Centers.” These visas entitle them to work in the United States for six years. After the six years, the worker “must decide whether to return home or seek citizenship. But he will do so under the normal rules and regulations of our naturalization laws.” Pence wants Christians involved in the process and is proposing some faith-based programs so the churches can help people with their paperwork, can teach them English, and integrate them into the communities. I think that his plan, which has gained interest in the White House and support on both sides of the Capitol, provides the basis of a good compromise. I would modify his requirement that people leave the country to apply for guest-worker visas—I think that could be done in federal facilities around the country and save money and time. And the criteria for certifying border security must be objective and reasonable. But these things can be accomplished. The point is that this is a good proposal that gets us out of the deadlock and promotes security and respect for the law in a humane and workable fashion. And it addresses the issues of workers without demonizing them. I hope you will get behind Pence’s proposal and call your senators and congressman. Given the contentious quality of the immigration debate, what is needed is support for people like Mike Pence, for whom faith and public service go hand-in-hand. Take action: Please call your congressman and senators and urge them to vote for the Pence Plan: No Amnesty Immigration Reform. Call 202-224-3121. Visit and to learn how to reach your two senators and congressman directly.
For Further Reading and Information
Please help support the Christian worldview ministry of BreakPoint by donating online today or calling 1-877-322-5527. Learn more about the Pence Plan: No Amnesty Immigration Reform. Read Rep. Pence’s speech, “Renewing the American Dream: The Real Rational.” Mike Pence, “Amnesty Isn’t the Answer,” USA Today, 11 July 2006, 12A. Read a transcript of Congressman Pence’s NPR interview on immigration. See Congressman Pence’s blog for more information on immigration. Sheryl Gay Stolberg, “Bush Signaling Shift in Stance on Immigration,” New York Times, 5 July 2006. Warren Smith, “My Dirty Little Secret,” Charlotte World, 11 July 2006. Tyler Cowen and Daniel M. Rothschild, “Blending In, Moving Up,” Washington Post, 12 June 2006, A21. T. M. Moore, “Strangers in Our Midst,” BreakPoint Online, 26 April 2006. Read past “BreakPoint” commentaries on immigration. Kevin Belmonte, Hero for Humanity (NavPress, 2002).


Chuck Colson



  • Facebook Icon in Gold
  • Twitter Icon in Gold
  • LinkedIn Icon in Gold

Sign up for the Daily Commentary